✓
Submitted›
✓
AI Review›
3
Human Review›
4
Decision›
5
Author Revision›
6
Published—
Loading manuscript…
AI Consensus — Key Criteria
Section-Level Scores
Agent Recommendation Summary
AI Review Synopsis
All Criteria — AI Scores & Your Decision
Section-by-Section Evaluation
Your Review Decision
Consolidated Review Report
Write your overall assessment below. This will be emailed to the author along with the AI agent scores and your criterion-level decisions.
Confidential Note to Editor (not shared with author)
Decision:
Not yet set
Pre-Submission Checklist